
Picture it: wealthy, gorgeous, married women abiding by conservative Southern values in a state like Texas while hiding same-sex attractions are sleeping with one another via extramarital queer relationships maintained with varying degrees of secrecy and/or boundaries. Yup, if you’re into Netflix’s The Hunting Wives, you better strap in for Bravo’s Small Town Trouble: Texas, baby!
“Jesus is not mad at me for scissoring,” Aaryn Williams, the Bravo show’s complicated lead (more on that later), tells costar Hailey Head in a scene from the official trailer.
Instead of Netflix’s fictional Maple Brook, the reality series is set in Boerne, Texas — a very real Country Hill town where 70.5% of residents still voted for Republican Ken Paxton despite the blue-nami that led Democrat James Talarico to victory.
Unlike flipping Texas blue, Boerne flipped out against the show itself, originally titled Secrets, Lies, Texas Wives. A petition (“Oppose reality TV shows harming Boerne’s reputation”) reached 900 signatures.
Yet the show litigated nothing about Boerne. It’s a small Texas town with churches, cowboys, and conservatives. “Groundbreaking,” to quote a Devil who wears Prada.
Even the premise of Small Town Trouble: Texas is, conceptually, a rodeo that Bravo has mastered over the last two decades: truth is stranger than fiction. We know.

It took one year from Fox’s evident hit show The O.C. to MTV’s groundbreaking reality series Laguna Beach, originally dubbed The Real Orange County and ornately billed as a real-life version of the beloved teen drama.
Grownups obviously had the appetite for “real” rumors, rivalries, and rendezvous, as the obsession with ABC’s Desperate Housewives turned the idea of a reality show named Behind the Gates into Bravo’s The Real Housewives: a reality TV franchise on the air for over 20 years that’s yielded many successful spinoffs around the world.
We’ve now met The Hunting Wives‘ tethered.
The queer thing about Small Town Trouble: Texas is precisely that it is basically about being queer!
(Except for Alli McAnelly, once crowned “Queen of Boerne,” who stands straight, safe, and corny the entire time…)
Three of the five female cast members — Aaryn Williams, Annari Uys, and Gabby Huffman — flat-out say they don’t identify as straight. The premiere ends on a suggestive note that maybe a fourth cast member, Hailey Head, is also pushing new boundaries (question mark???).
Honestly, I find the men’s positioning in Small Town Trouble: Texas sort of interesting and unusual. For one, they’re actually credited as cast members, just like the women, which isn’t a given on this type of show.
Yeah, the men on The Real Housewives are also only relevant as supporting characters to the female-led narratives. However, from a production standpoint, something feels different about how these men are introduced and much more contextualized compared to the usual Housewives dismissal.
It feels jolting — I’m sure excitingly to some, and negatively to others — to see the grand premiere of Small Town Trouble: Texas introducing these men named Nick Williams, Duan Uys, Jordan Huffman, Josh Marsalis, and Blake McAnelly, then right away featuring them having wildly candid, televised discussions about being a “cuck,” or about having open relationships with different rules.
Even the men who don’t say much seem to be saying something about being pro or against the open relationships that map out this show, despite it being a topic most straight couples tend to stay silent about.
Worst-case scenario: These men perhaps don’t realize their value to the overall narrative of the series is to show viewers how they react to and navigate their wives experiencing these queer awakenings.
Best-case scenario: These men do understand their supportive roles and won’t be horrible to their wives after consenting to them exploring their queerness. Is that a lot to expect from the (often very fragile) masculinity of straight men? Yes, it is.
The problem with even the best possible read of Small Town Trouble: Texas is that nothing feels more jolting than Aaryn Williams, formerly (and still mostly) known as Aaryn Gries, anchoring a show about small-town prejudice and queer self-discovery.
Sure, this premiere is graciously edited to help viewers imagine and empathize with how Aaryn’s upbringing led to her being extremely racist and homophobic in her reality TV debut on Big Brother season 15, which aired in 2013.
Aaryn’s husband, Nick, adds to this moment of reflection with a memory of his own: visiting her father’s hometown bar. According to Nick, that bar had Barack Obama’s face hung on a dartboard. Nick reveals that he’s an Army veteran, and claims that he was involved in Obama’s inauguration security detail.
But that’s where the story stops, which makes you wonder if the memory is actually saying anything. Was Nick offended by the former president’s face on the dartboard? Did Nick assume that Aaryn’s father could’ve made his job harder? But, like, it is just a bar in a random town, so did Aaryn’s father put it there or comment that he agreed with it?
Nick essentially asks us to assume that he assumed something about Aaryn’s father. And that story, in Nick’s mind, seemingly confirms that Aaryn’s family was really that racist. I’m not sure the points connect in any meaningful way.
Before she was Aaryn Williams, she was Aaryn Gries: a 22-year-old college student who appeared on CBS as a houseguest on Big Brother 15. Y’know, the show that’s literally about a house with 24-hour live feeds documenting everything that’s said and done.
I’ll include a video below that includes lots of racist and homophobic remarks from Big Brother 15, many of which involve Aaryn. I don’t think you need to watch it, or even should, but it’s there if you want to see it for yourself.
Besides actual verbal fights that could’ve escalated into physical altercations: Aaryn targeted an Asian contestant by mocking Asian accents; Aaryn also told her allies not to speak in the dark in case a Black contestant was in the room and they couldn’t see the person; and Aaryn targeted a gay contestant by calling him slurs, claiming viewers would favor him simply because he’s gay, then remarking no one would respect his game moves as he gained power.
Ironically, that gay contestant is named Andy Herren, and he won that season. He also played a solid game that gets buried in all this BB15 problematic muck.
When Aaryn stepped onto the stage after her elimination, the show’s live audience literally booed her. She was signed to a modeling agency at the time, but the contract was dropped before she even left the CBS lot.
For me, Aaryn’s entire narrative from this premiere special falls apart when she casually mentions that her first time with a woman happened during the jury house in her season of Big Brother.
If you’re unfamiliar with the format: Only nine players go to the jury house. That season had six female jury members, Aaryn being one of them. By saying that her first experience with a woman was on the Big Brother jury house, Aaryn just outed one of the only five women who could’ve been there with her.
So that’s great.
Leading up to this premiere, Reality Blurred criticized platforming an infamous Big Brother racism scandal after firing cast members from Vanderpump Rules and Salt Lake City for racist behaviors just a few years ago.
Iconic Big Brother 24 winner Taylor Hale — who’ll compete on Peacock’s The Traitors season 5 this January! — also criticized the decision.
“I actually think it’s really weird to focus on rehabbing racist people instead of focusing on the people they actually caused harm to. But it’s not like I would know anything about that,” she said.
I do think this new show has multiple paths toward success. It can resonate with an audience that views the queerness as just erotic and isn’t concerned at all with anyone’s problematic remarks. But it also has interesting queer women, like Gabby and Annari. And while I wouldn’t guess Hailey is joining this fateful, messy, sapphic love triangle, something about her naivete reads as brutally sincere, which feels surprising and makes me curious to keep checking in.
If you watch this show with existing complicated feelings about Aaryn, the premiere makes you curious enough to see her walk this tightrope back into reality TV. But somewhere between the traditional family portraits, the liberated queer woman flirting with anyone on sight, and calling herself a “monster on the hill” upon Boerne, Aaryn’s supposed comeback story doesn’t feel fully fleshed out yet.
Small Town Trouble: Texas airs new episodes every Wednesday on Bravo with next-day streaming on Peacock.












